Pizza Night in Kalamazoo
4 stops · about 2 hours · Updated October 6, 2026
Advertisement
Build a pizza night in Kalamazoo, MI around Papa Pete’s at 502 S Burdick St, where pizza shares the menu with Greek and American food. Open daily from 4 p.m. to 2 a.m., the restaurant and bar also has frequent live music, weekly salsa dancing, karaoke nights, and bar games. For the drink afterward, choose Alley Cat at 266 E Michigan Ave, Suite B, for cocktails, beer, wine, and a casual, cozy setting with outdoor seating. Its Friday and Saturday hours run until 1 a.m. One Well Brewing at 4213 Portage Street offers another finish: beer, food, and games together, with free lot and street parking. For a Turkish-food alternative to the pizza start, Ayasofya Turkish Restaurant serves halal shawarma, kebabs, mezes, and freshly baked pita at 1528 W Michigan Ave.
Pizza
Stop 1
Ayasofya Turkish Restaurant
4.7(373)Kalamazoo
Ayasofya Turkish Restaurant offers a halal Turkish meal with shawarma, kebabs, mezes, freshly baked pita, and vegan and vegetarian options.
Stop 2
Papa Pete's
4.4(664)Kalamazoo
Papa Pete’s pairs pizza with Greek and American food, frequent live music, weekly salsa dancing, and daily hours until 2 a.m.
A drink after
Stop 3
Alley Cat
4.9(39)Kalamazoo
Alley Cat combines cocktails and happy-hour food and drinks with karaoke, trivia, bar games, and outdoor seating in a casual, cozy setting.
Stop 4
One Well Brewing
4.7(1404)Kalamazoo
One Well Brewing brings beer, food, and games together with an on-site bar, free parking, and wheelchair-accessible seating for an activity-based evening.
