Last updated October 5, 2026 · ranked from 3,263 Google reviews · How we rank
This list ranks 10 sandwich shops in and around Kalamazoo, MI, led by Ray Ray's Italian Beef & Sausage, Caffè Casa and Artisan Sandwich Company. Together they have 3,263 Google reviews; Ray Ray's Italian Beef & Sausage has the highest Google rating on the list at 4.7. Every place on the list is in Kalamazoo, MI. Rankings weigh Google rating, review volume, how complete and current each listing is, and our own notes on each place.
A 4.7-star Google rating across 1,152 reviews and lowest-tier pricing put Ray Ray's Italian Beef & Sausage at No. 1. At 1715 Miller Rd in Kalamazoo, MI, the compact shop serves Italian-style sandwiches alongside barbecue and hot dogs. Chicago sports decor gives the casual counter-service space a distinct setting, with seating for eating in and takeout or delivery for meals elsewhere. Free lot and street parking and a children's menu add practical appeal for lunch or dinner.
Italian-style sandwiches
Chicago sports decor
Lowest-tier pricing
“Great service and great atmosphere. Being from the Chicago area, it was cool to see all the memorabilia. The young lady (I believe she is the daughter of the owner) was super pleasant and helpful. She even found a way to charge me for…”
Work at Ray Ray's Italian Beef & Sausage? Get your badge
Sandwiches and flavorful soup draw praise at Caffè Casa, whose 4.7 Google rating across 278 reviews supports its No. 2 ranking. This women-owned shop at 128 S Kalamazoo Mall in Kalamazoo, MI pairs sandwiches with espresso, tea and baked goods in a relaxed, quiet setting. Reviewers also note kind staff and timely food service during busy periods. Vegan and vegetarian options broaden the menu, while indoor seating, outdoor tables and takeout offer several ways to settle in for lunch or take it along.
Sandwiches and soup
Vegan options
Outdoor seating
“Stop reading this and just come find your new favorite thing. From pastries to sandwiches and teas and coffees- you won’t be disappointed. The plants are SICK. The entire establishment has a really calming and earthy feel to it. Cool sta…”
Local bread baked fresh daily anchors Artisan Sandwich Company’s third-place ranking in Kalamazoo, MI, backed by a 4.7 Google rating from 287 reviews. Reviewers praise the sandwiches, fair prices, generous portions, and friendly recommendations. At 348 S Kalamazoo Mall, its listed offerings include breakfast, brunch, lunch, and vegetarian options, while catering draws praise from a repeat organizational customer. Those strengths support its ranking, though one review reports that the shop is permanently closed.
Fresh local bread
Praised portion sizes
Vegetarian options
“This sandwhich shop is easily one of the best in town. It’s consistently busy so you know it’s well loved and great quality food. Always a solid choice for lunch. :)”
Artisan sandwiches anchor The Grazing Table Kalamazoo’s case for No. 4, alongside a 4.6 Google rating from 196 reviews. This locally owned café at 123 E South St in Kalamazoo, MI grew out of a charcuterie business and still serves signature boards alongside brunch and lunch. Vegetarian and vegan offerings broaden the choices, while espresso drinks and mocktails round out a midday meal. A bright interior, outdoor seating and online ordering give customers several ways to enjoy lunch during its Tuesday–Saturday, 11 a.m.–3 p.m. hours.
Artisan sandwiches
Signature charcuterie boards
Outdoor seating
“Extremely disappointing and unprofessional experience.
We scheduled a pickup for a large charcuterie board for my mother-in-law’s memorial service and had a series of four emails confirming the details directly with the owner, Joey.
Wh…”
Homemade Italian sausage and a history in Kalamazoo, MI dating to 1984 give Papa's Italian Sausage a distinct identity among the city's sandwich shops. Its No. 5 placement is supported by a 4.6 Google rating from 321 reviews, with one reviewer praising both the service and quick food preparation. Located at 543 E Ransom St, the shop describes itself as the home of the Bella Supreme. Counter service, indoor and outdoor seating, takeout, and a drive-through provide several ways to stop for lunch or dinner.
Homemade Italian sausage
Serving since 1984
Drive-through available
“Food was great and service was very good. Quick to get my food out.”
Daily hours from 9 a.m. to 10 p.m. and several ordering options help Jimmy John's earn rank 6. At 3116 S Westnedge Ave in Kalamazoo, MI, this counter-service shop specializes in sub and club sandwiches, with vegetarian options and signature potato chips. Its Google rating is 4 out of 5 across 324 reviews. Dine-in seating, outdoor seating, takeout, and a drive-through offer flexibility, though the supplied reviews include complaints about delivery and order accuracy. A free parking lot adds convenience.
Sub and club sandwiches
Drive-through available
Open daily
“Food was not delivered. Manager was rude on phone.”
Daily 9 a.m.–10 p.m. hours and several ordering options help Jimmy John's earn rank 7. At 3606 S Sprinkle Rd in Kalamazoo, MI, this counter-service chain specializes in sub and club sandwiches, with signature potato chips available alongside them. Its Google rating is 4.1 from 179 reviews. Customers can dine in, use the drive-through, pick up takeout, or order delivery. Free parking and wheelchair-accessible seating add practical reasons to keep this location on the list.
Sub and club sandwiches
Drive-through available
Open daily
“I waited 12 minutes at the window and was the only one in line at 8:08 pm Monday 9/21. Was told it just got done and that I should have spoke to him at the speaker. I did and was told to pull up to the window. He became defensive. Seemed…”
Build-your-own sandwiches, a low price level, and daily 9 a.m.–9 p.m. hours give this Subway practical appeal at No. 8. Located at 3025 Oakland Dr in Kalamazoo, MI, the counter-service shop has a 4-out-of-5 Google rating from 108 reviews. Vegetarian options and salads broaden the choices, while dine-in, takeout, and delivery accommodate different routines. A quiet setting suits solo meals, and free lot and street parking make stopping in straightforward.
Sub and club sandwiches, a low price level, and flexible ordering options earn Jimmy John's its No. 9 spot. Located at 232 W Michigan Ave in Kalamazoo, MI, the counter-service shop offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery, with vegetarian choices available. Positive reviews praise tasty food and quick online-order fulfillment, while reports of incorrect orders and delivery problems temper its 3.8-star rating across 169 Google reviews. Weekday hours run from 10 a.m. to 9 p.m.; weekend service ends at 4 p.m.
Sub and club sandwiches
Vegetarian choices available
Dine-in and takeout
“ordered delivery “freaky fast” and it was outsourced to uber instead. They didn’t bring my drink and the only options from the store were to refund or credit the account”
Low prices and hours stretching to 11 p.m. Monday through Saturday give Chicago Subs & Grill its practical appeal at No. 10. Located at 1408 Portage Street in Kalamazoo, MI, this casual sandwich shop serves lunch and dinner with counter service and options for takeout or delivery. Free lot and street parking add convenience for pickup visits. Its 3.8-star Google rating from 249 reviews accompanies a listing built around inexpensive comfort food, quick bites and solo dining.
Inexpensive comfort food
Open until 11
Takeout and delivery
“I order chicken sandwich and fries. It was ok. Throw up shortly after. I asked the lady there if they cooked their food in old grease. She was already looking like she had an attitude, rolling her eyes. She yelled at me and told me to…”
Ratings and review counts shown are Google ratings, displayed with attribution.
How we ranked this list
Each sandwich shop is scored on a Bayesian-weighted rating (its rating adjusted for how many reviews it has compared with the Kalamazoo category average), how recently we verified its details, and how complete its listing is. Scores and ranks are stored, so the order only changes when the underlying data changes.
Which sandwich shops in Kalamazoo, MI have the highest Google ratings?
Ray Ray’s Italian Beef & Sausage, Artisan Sandwich Company, and Caffè Casa share the highest listed rating at 4.7. Their review counts are 1,152, 287, and 278, respectively. Papa’s Italian Sausage and The Grazing Table follow at 4.6, with 321 and 196 reviews.
Where can I get a sandwich late at night in Kalamazoo, MI?
Jimmy John’s at 1128 W Michigan Ave is open from 10 a.m. to midnight every day. Chicago Subs & Grill at 1408 Portage Street operates from 11 a.m. to 11 p.m. Monday through Saturday. Ray Ray’s closes at 10 p.m. Friday and Saturday and at 9 p.m. Tuesday through Thursday.
Which sandwich spots offer vegetarian or vegan options?
Caffè Casa at 128 S Kalamazoo Mall and The Grazing Table at 123 E South St both list vegan and vegetarian offerings. Vegetarian options are also listed at Subway at 125 E Michigan Ave and Jimmy John’s at 3116 S Westnedge Ave, 1128 W Michigan Ave, and 232 W Michigan Ave.
Which sandwich shops have drive-through service in Kalamazoo, MI?
Papa’s Italian Sausage at 543 E Ransom St and Jimmy John’s at 3116 S Westnedge Ave and 3606 S Sprinkle Rd offer drive-through service. Both Jimmy John’s locations are open 9 a.m.–10 p.m. daily. Papa’s closes at 5 p.m. Monday and Tuesday and at 8 p.m. Wednesday through Saturday.
Where can I have a sandwich with coffee and outdoor seating?
Caffè Casa offers sandwiches, espresso, tea, baked goods, and outdoor seating, with hours of 7:30 a.m.–4 p.m. Monday through Saturday. The Grazing Table offers artisan sandwiches, espresso drinks, and outdoor seating where dogs are allowed; its hours are 11 a.m.–3 p.m. Tuesday through Saturday. Both have Wi-Fi.
1
